@212 CHAP 2 ÚÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ¿ ³SELECTION OF LEGAL ENTITY -- OVERVIEW OF CHOICES³ ÀÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÙ @Q "The hardest thing in the world to understand is @Q Income Tax." -- Albert Einstein @IF901xx]Your business has not yet started up. Thus you still have an @IF901xx]opportunity to select the most favorable type of legal entity @IF901xx]for @NAME when it comes into being. @IF901xx] @IF901xx]The following outline and summary will give you a fairly de- @IF901xx]tailed overview of which type of entity is likely to be best @IF901xx]for your particular business, which you have indicated is in @IF901xx]the field of @BUSTYPE. @IF901xx] @IF900xx]Your firm, @NAME, has already selected @IF900xx]a form of doing business, which is a @ENTITY. @IF900xx] @IF900xx]However, it is possible that your choice of legal entity is @IF900xx]not the optimum alternative for your particular business and @IF900xx]personal needs. The following outline and summary will give @IF900xx]you some basic guidance as to whether you should explore the @IF900xx]possibility of switching to some other legal form of business @IF900xx]organization at this point in the game. @IF900xx] Choosing the "best" legal form or entity for your business is rarely an easy decision to make. Each form of business, sole proprietorship, partnership, and corporation, has its own benefits and shortcomings, which vary in degree depend- ing on the kind and size of your business, your tax situa- tion, profitability, personal predilections, and numerous other factors, some of which may seem important to you, others of which may not. Thus there is often no "right" answer as to which legal entity you should select for oper- ating your business. The following is a thumbnail sketch or overview of some of the major advantages and disadvantages of sole proprietor- ships, partnerships, and corporations. Where there are differences between a general partnership and a limited partnership, or between a regular ("C") corporation and an S corporation, separate comments are shown for each. Other- wise, the comments regarding partnerships apply to both general and limited partnerships, and the comments regard- ing corporations relate to both regular and S corporations. @CODE: AL AZ AR CO DE FL GA ID IL IN IA KS LA MD MI MN MT NB NV ND OK RI SD TX UT VA WV WY Because your state, along with 27 others, has adopted a new kind of legal entity, called a "limited liability company," which is much like a partnership, but with limited liability for all its owners, the following discussion also includes consideration of such "LLCs" in the state of @STATE. @CODE:OF As a general rule, it seems that some types of businesses are much more likely than others to benefit from adopting a certain legal form, as in the case of the following (press key for details on highlighted words): .äProfessional service firmsè(law, accounting, etc.); \113 .äCapital-intensive firmsèneeding to accumulate capital; \114 .äReal estate rentalèbusinesses, in general; and \115 .äAuthors, inventorsèand software developers receiv- \116 ing royalty income for licensing intellectual property. SIMPLICITY IN OPERATION AND FORMATION: .äProprietorshipè Simplest to establish and operate. \110 .äGeneral Partnershipè Relatively simple, informal, but \111 is usually desirable to have for- mal written agreement between the partners. .äLimited Partnershipè More complex and expensive than \112 other unincorporated forms of business to establish. Requires written agreement, filing of cer- tificate. Managed by general partners only. @CODE: AL AZ AR CO DE FL GA ID IL IN IA KS LA MD MI MN MT NB NV ND OK RI SD TX UT VA WV WY .äLim. Liability Co.è A new type of entity, which your \406 lawyer may not yet be very famil- iar with. Requires written arti- cles of organization, roughly comparable to a corporation or a limited partnership in terms of complexity in formation. Can be formed under the state laws of @STATE. @CODE:OF @CODE: IL (Note, however: The Illinois LLC law does not go into effect until January 1, 1994.) @CODE:OF .äRegular Corporationè Requires most formality in estab- \135\231 lishment and operation, generally. .äS Corporationè Same as regular corporation, but \234 requires close oversight by a tax advisor, an additional cost. LIABILITY FOR DEBTS, TAXES & OTHER CLAIMS: . Proprietorship Owner has unlimited personal liability. . General Partnership Partners all have unlimited per- sonal liability. . Limited Partnership General partners are personally liable; limited partners are li- able only to the extent of their investment, generally. @CODE: AL AZ AR CO DE FL GA ID IL IN IA KS LA MD MI MN MT NB NV ND OK RI SD TX UT VA WV WY . Lim. Liability Co. "Members" (owners) not generally liable for company's debts, under the state laws of @STATE. But may have to guarantee loans, as a practical matter, if compa- ny is to be able to borrow money. Also, corporate officers may be liable for failure to withhold and pay over to IRS, withholding taxes on employees' wages. @CODE:OF . Corporation Stockholders not generally li- able for corporate debts, but often have to guarantee loans, as a practical matter, if cor- poration is to borrow money. Also, corporate officers may be liable for failure to withhold and pay over to IRS, withholding taxes on employees' wages. FEDERAL INCOME TAXATION OF BUSINESS PROFITS: . Proprietorship Taxed to owner at individual tax rates of up to 31% or more in 1992 and 1993. . Partnership Taxed to partners at their indiv- idual tax rates. @CODE: AL AZ AR CO DE FL GA ID IL IN IA KS LA MD MI MN MT NB NV ND OK RI SD TX UT VA WV WY . Lim. Liability Co. Taxed to owners at their individ- ual tax rates, if organized so as to be taxed as a partnership for federal income tax purposes. @CODE:OF @CODE: FL (Note, however, that for Florida state income tax purposes, an LLC is taxed as a corporation.) @CODE:OF . Regular Corporation Taxed to corporation at rates higher than those of individuals (maximum of 34% or 39% in 1992 and 1993). . S Corporation Taxed to individual owners at their individual rates (but cer- tain gains are taxable to the corporation as well). DOUBLE TAXATION IF PROFITS ARE WITHDRAWN FROM THE BUSINESS: . Proprietorship No. . Partnership No. @CODE: AL AZ AR CO DE FL GA ID IL IN IA KS LA MD MI MN MT NB NV ND OK RI SD TX UT VA WV WY . Lim. Liability Co. No, generally, if treated for tax purposes as a partnership. @CODE:OF . Regular Corporation Yes. (But major exception exists foräreasonable compensationè that \105 is paid to owners who are employ- ees of the corporation.) . S Corporation No, in general. DEDUCTION OF LOSSES BY OWNERS: . Proprietorship Yes. . Partnership Yes. Limited partner's deduc- tions generally cannot exceed the amount he or she has invested in a limited partnership interest (except for real estate, in some instances). @CODE: AL AZ AR CO DE FL GA ID IL IN IA KS LA MD MI MN MT NB NV ND OK RI SD TX UT VA WV WY . Lim. Liability Co. Yes, generally, if treated as a partnership for tax purposes. Tax treatment is not totally resolved yet, but may actually have some advantages over limited partner- ships for holding real estate. @CODE:OF . Regular Corporation No. Corporation must carry over any initial losses until able to offset them against future prof- its, if ever. . S Corporation Yes, in general, for federal tax purposes. Loss for a shareholder is limited to investment in his or her stock, plus amount loaned to corporation. SOCIAL SECURITY TAXES ON EARNINGS OF OWNER FROM THE BUSINESS: . Proprietorship 15.3% of owner'säself-employmentè \262 earnings in 1993, up to $57,600 of income, plus 2.9% of S/E in- come over $57,600, to $135,000. Half of the S/E tax is deductible for income tax purposes. . Partnership 15.3% of each partner's share of self-employment earnings from the business in 1993, on up to $57,600 of such earnings, plus 2.9% on excess over $57,600 (up to maximum S/E income of $135,000). @CODE: AL AZ AR CO DE FL GA ID IL IN IA KS LA MD MI MN MT NB NV ND OK RI SD TX UT VA WV WY . Lim. Liability Co. Same as partnership, if LLC is is organized in such as way as to be recognized as a partnership for tax purposes. @CODE:OF . Corporation Owner/employee of corporation pays 7.65% on his or her salary and corporation also pays 7.65%. TotaläSocial Security (FICA) taxè \258 is 15.3% of up to $57,600 of sal- ary in 1993 (plus 2.9% on excess over $57,600, up to maximum S/E income of $135,000). UNEMPLOYMENT TAXES ON EARNINGS OF OWNER FROM THE BUSINESS: . Proprietorship None. . Partnership None. @CODE: AL AZ AR CO DE FL GA ID IL IN IA KS LA MD MI MN MT NB NV ND OK RI SD TX UT VA WV WY . Lim. Liability Co. None, if treated as partnership. @CODE:OF . Corporation Yes. äUnemployment taxesè (state \260 and federal) apply to salaries paid to owners. RETIREMENT PLANS: . Proprietorship Keogh plan. Deductions, other features now generally the same as for corporate pension and profit sharing plans. But a par- ticipant who is owner cannot bor- row from a Keogh plan. . Partnership Keogh plan. Same as for sole proprietorship except that the prohibition on borrowing from plan applies to any 10% or greater partner. @CODE: AL AZ AR CO DE FL GA ID IL IN IA KS LA MD MI MN MT NB NV ND OK RI SD TX UT VA WV WY . Lim. Liability Co. Same as for partnership, if rec- ognized as partnership for tax purposes. @CODE:OF . Regular Corporation Corporate retirement plans no longer are significantly better than Keogh plans. Deduction limits same now as for Keogh. But participants can borrow from corporate plan, within limits. . S Corporation Plans now essentially identical to regular corporate retirement plans, except that "shareholder- employee" (owning 5% or more of the stock) of S corporation can- not borrow from retirement plan. TAX TREATMENT OF MEDICAL, DISABILITY, AND GROUP-TERM LIFE INSURANCE ON OWNERS: . Proprietorship Not deductible, except that part of medical expenses may be an itemized deduction on owner's tax return, including medical insurance premiums. But 25% of medical insurance on owner is now allowed as a deduction in computing adjusted gross income. . Partnership See proprietorship, above. @CODE: AL AZ AR CO DE FL GA ID IL IN IA KS LA MD MI MN MT NB NV ND OK RI SD TX UT VA WV WY . Lim. Liability Co. Same as partnership, if treated as partnership for tax purposes. @CODE:OF . Regular Corporation Corporation may be able to de- duct theämedical insuranceèprem- \241 ium or reimbursements paid under a medical reimbursement plan. Generally not taxable to the em- ployee, even if employee is an owner, if plan is not considered discriminatory. Similar treat- ment is provided forädisabilityè \240 coverage and up to $50,000 of coverage (per employee) for ägroup term life insuranceèplans. \242 . S Corporation Fringe benefits for 2% sharehol- ders may be deductible by corpor- ation, but such expense will be treated like additional (taxable) compensation to shareholder- employees who own more than 2% of the stock of the company. (But may not be subject to FICA tax in the case of medical insur- ance, if such coverage is provid- ed to employees generally by the S corporation.) TAXATION OF DIVIDENDS RECEIVED ON INVESTMENTS: . Proprietorship Dividends received on stock in- vestments are fully taxable to owner. . Partnership Dividends taxable to individual partners. See proprietorship, above. @CODE: AL AZ AR CO DE FL GA ID IL IN IA KS LA MD MI MN MT NB NV ND OK RI SD TX UT VA WV WY . Lim. Liability Co. Dividends taxable to individual members, if treated as partner- ship for tax purposes. @CODE:OF . Regular Corporation Dividends are taxable to the cor- poration. But aäspecial deductionè \245 is allowed for 70% of the divi- dends received, generally (unless stock is purchased with borrowed money), an important tax advan- tage. . S Corporation Dividends are taxable to indiv- idual shareholders of the S cor- poration, as in the case of divi- dends received by a partnership.